Devoted, Dieting, Dessert-eaters in Denial
you know who you are
I subscribe to a few publications one would call “women’s magazines” – and it never ceases to amaze me that these publications always seem to have two themes highlighted on the cover: Diets and rich foods.
It never fails: Ten pages of desserts and hi-cal casseroles and ten pages of exercise tips and diets. Talk about schizophrenic!
But when I think about the women I know well, they seem to be examples of this dichotomy – the devoted dieting, dessert eaters in denial. Names have been changed to protect the plump.
Roberta: According to Roberta she has lost over 589 pounds, yet she looks identical to the day I met her – round and overweight. The minute she walks in the door she announces: How do I look? I lost 12 pounds. I can fit into clothes I haven’t worn in years. One thing Roberta doesn’t do is announce when she has gained weight which must be about every other week. Otherwise she would have died years ago when she announced for the 18th time that she’d lost 10 pounds.
Marla: Marla’s a gym rat. Everyday she gets up at 6 am to go to the gym for a 45 minute workout. From the gym, she goes directly to the diner where she orders bacon and eggs, home fries, toast and coffee. Oh yes, she’ll have that short stack too – see she’s worked out and quite hungry. Marla is forever on a diet tread mill. She expends calories for sure, but then eats more than she should which gives her a one pound weight gain per week. If Marla didn’t go to the gym and didn’t then go to the diner, she’d probably be ahead of the game.
Lorna: Lorna uses Sweet 'n Lo in her coffee and only drinks Diet Coke. She always orders a Diet Coke with her Big Mac and super-sized fries. Lorna thinks sugar is responsible for the size of American women’s hips. Apparently she doesn’t think a Big Mac with its 800 plus calories has a thing to do with her broadening beam. Her ticket to gluttony is that one calorie Diet Coke.
Jewel: Jewel has bulges everywhere because she wears a size 12. She tells everyone she wears a size 12, same size as when she got married. The trouble is Jewel’s ass is a size 16. It isn’t a pretty sight to see her bulging tummy which sticks out in the front as much as her butt sticks out in the back, zipper squeaking under the strain of that size 16 being stuffed in those size 12s. All Jewel’s pants fit like they’re panty hose. Fabric is always straining at the seams exposing the weary stitching that is ready to pop open at any moment, leaving Jewel bare-ass naked.
Jean: Jean eats like a bird. We all go out to lunch and order Philly Cheesesteak sandwiches except Jean who’ll just have a salad, thank you. She goes to the salad bar and proceeds to dump 3 pounds of cheese, 4 pounds of croutons and 2 pounds of turkey and ham onto her salad. Then comes the rich thick creamy blue cheese salad dressing and when she walks back to the table with her salad, she’s carrying about 1400 calories on her plate. Jean loves to say: Well, since I only had a salad I’m going to treat myself to dessert. The dessert adds another 675 calories to her meal and she waddles out of the restaurant feeling superior to the Cheesesteak eaters even though she’s had double or triple the calories that we’ve had.
Sarah: Sarah is a taster and sampler. She’s tastes everything she’s cooking and samples everything she’s serving about 31 times until she’s actually eaten a full meal before she sits down to eat. She is also a kids’ plate cleaner. The kids get up from lunch and she finishes off the mac and cheese, the potato chips, the crusts from the peanut butter and jelly, adding in some more calories before she sits down to eat her very small and sensible lunch.
Diane: Diane is a sneak eater. She will not eat in front of you for love or money. But walk out of her kitchen, count to 7 and walk back in and you’ll find her with her mouth stuffed. She’ll try to swallow quickly so you don’t notice, but we all have her number. If you are bored and want to be naughty, just walk out of her kitchen and back in again and I guarantee you’ll find her with a mouthful of something she’s shoved in right after you walked out.
Karla: Karla says she has a metabolism problem. According to her she never eats. “I had nothing for breakfast and nothing for lunch and just steamed salmon and a salad for dinner.” Well Karla, I hate to be cruel, but you are eating something at some time or you couldn’t weigh over 200 pounds. Karla will also tell you that she is big boned and that’s why she appears overweight. Honey, there are no bones in your butt and no bones in your double chin. If one really doesn't eat --then one really loses weight.
My chunky chums will point to me and say: You are so lucky, you never gain weight. That’s not true and luck has nothing to do with it.
I just have taken to heart what my dear mother used to tell me on the subject of weight gain:
What doesn’t go through the lips won’t go on the hips.
There were no fat people in the concentration camps no matter what their metabolism was or how big boned they were.
Never take in more calories than you are expending.
They should put those dieting tips on the cover of the women’s magazines but it’s too simple and too true. So instead they put the picture of the frosted double-fudge brownie and the woman in tights who’s showing off her slim figure that she got by not eating the frosted double-fudge brownie.
Bon Appetit!
you know who you are
I subscribe to a few publications one would call “women’s magazines” – and it never ceases to amaze me that these publications always seem to have two themes highlighted on the cover: Diets and rich foods.
It never fails: Ten pages of desserts and hi-cal casseroles and ten pages of exercise tips and diets. Talk about schizophrenic!
But when I think about the women I know well, they seem to be examples of this dichotomy – the devoted dieting, dessert eaters in denial. Names have been changed to protect the plump.
Roberta: According to Roberta she has lost over 589 pounds, yet she looks identical to the day I met her – round and overweight. The minute she walks in the door she announces: How do I look? I lost 12 pounds. I can fit into clothes I haven’t worn in years. One thing Roberta doesn’t do is announce when she has gained weight which must be about every other week. Otherwise she would have died years ago when she announced for the 18th time that she’d lost 10 pounds.
Marla: Marla’s a gym rat. Everyday she gets up at 6 am to go to the gym for a 45 minute workout. From the gym, she goes directly to the diner where she orders bacon and eggs, home fries, toast and coffee. Oh yes, she’ll have that short stack too – see she’s worked out and quite hungry. Marla is forever on a diet tread mill. She expends calories for sure, but then eats more than she should which gives her a one pound weight gain per week. If Marla didn’t go to the gym and didn’t then go to the diner, she’d probably be ahead of the game.
Lorna: Lorna uses Sweet 'n Lo in her coffee and only drinks Diet Coke. She always orders a Diet Coke with her Big Mac and super-sized fries. Lorna thinks sugar is responsible for the size of American women’s hips. Apparently she doesn’t think a Big Mac with its 800 plus calories has a thing to do with her broadening beam. Her ticket to gluttony is that one calorie Diet Coke.
Jewel: Jewel has bulges everywhere because she wears a size 12. She tells everyone she wears a size 12, same size as when she got married. The trouble is Jewel’s ass is a size 16. It isn’t a pretty sight to see her bulging tummy which sticks out in the front as much as her butt sticks out in the back, zipper squeaking under the strain of that size 16 being stuffed in those size 12s. All Jewel’s pants fit like they’re panty hose. Fabric is always straining at the seams exposing the weary stitching that is ready to pop open at any moment, leaving Jewel bare-ass naked.
Jean: Jean eats like a bird. We all go out to lunch and order Philly Cheesesteak sandwiches except Jean who’ll just have a salad, thank you. She goes to the salad bar and proceeds to dump 3 pounds of cheese, 4 pounds of croutons and 2 pounds of turkey and ham onto her salad. Then comes the rich thick creamy blue cheese salad dressing and when she walks back to the table with her salad, she’s carrying about 1400 calories on her plate. Jean loves to say: Well, since I only had a salad I’m going to treat myself to dessert. The dessert adds another 675 calories to her meal and she waddles out of the restaurant feeling superior to the Cheesesteak eaters even though she’s had double or triple the calories that we’ve had.
Sarah: Sarah is a taster and sampler. She’s tastes everything she’s cooking and samples everything she’s serving about 31 times until she’s actually eaten a full meal before she sits down to eat. She is also a kids’ plate cleaner. The kids get up from lunch and she finishes off the mac and cheese, the potato chips, the crusts from the peanut butter and jelly, adding in some more calories before she sits down to eat her very small and sensible lunch.
Diane: Diane is a sneak eater. She will not eat in front of you for love or money. But walk out of her kitchen, count to 7 and walk back in and you’ll find her with her mouth stuffed. She’ll try to swallow quickly so you don’t notice, but we all have her number. If you are bored and want to be naughty, just walk out of her kitchen and back in again and I guarantee you’ll find her with a mouthful of something she’s shoved in right after you walked out.
Karla: Karla says she has a metabolism problem. According to her she never eats. “I had nothing for breakfast and nothing for lunch and just steamed salmon and a salad for dinner.” Well Karla, I hate to be cruel, but you are eating something at some time or you couldn’t weigh over 200 pounds. Karla will also tell you that she is big boned and that’s why she appears overweight. Honey, there are no bones in your butt and no bones in your double chin. If one really doesn't eat --then one really loses weight.
My chunky chums will point to me and say: You are so lucky, you never gain weight. That’s not true and luck has nothing to do with it.
I just have taken to heart what my dear mother used to tell me on the subject of weight gain:
What doesn’t go through the lips won’t go on the hips.
There were no fat people in the concentration camps no matter what their metabolism was or how big boned they were.
Never take in more calories than you are expending.
They should put those dieting tips on the cover of the women’s magazines but it’s too simple and too true. So instead they put the picture of the frosted double-fudge brownie and the woman in tights who’s showing off her slim figure that she got by not eating the frosted double-fudge brownie.
Bon Appetit!
15 Comments:
You know, it's quite strange, but yesterday I was reading an autobiography of a popular Russian writer, who used the exact same phrase you did about concentration camp survivors - and actually put herself through their diet! Maybe it's a sign... (or a hint!)
Who would ever put themselves through a diet of crumbs and foul water just to be thin? Awful. I'll be the Russian writer didn't stay on that diet very long.
I hesitated to use my mother's concentration camp phrase - but the people who say they eat *nothing* are not telling the truth and it is those people that you want to remind exactly what eating nothing or next to nothing looks like.
I am glad to see that you are talking (writing?) about something other than being sick. I hope you are feeling better. And I hope I am not being too much of a bother by asking you these silly questions. But what is "blog rolling"?
Also, the reason that dieting is so big, especially in the US is that no one wants to get off their asses and do any exercise. Which is of course only another symptom of a much larger problem. The underlying problem is patriarchy and the way that women are made to feel that they have to be sexy for men and even for other women. And of course that skinny is sexy.
thanks for your time...
Golly, the system is slow today.
MB: Love your ladies. I have to say I relate to almost all of them in different ways and at different times.
I'd like to go on a nice diet. Not the concentration camp diet Irina... How bout a warm and cozy eat whatever you want so long as it's no bigger than the size of your fist.
Or...eat all veggies, no soda, no bread.
Or as MB will probably suggest...everything in moderation, including moderation!
HI AP - welcome back and yes, I finally am feeling better. Thought I should stop writing my blog and start on a will a few days ago -- but it looks like I'm winning the viral battle now.
BlogRolling is a one-stop linklist manager for your blog or journal, helping you manage your ever-evolving linklist with ease.
That's what they tell you on their web site, but so far I can't get it to work. Perhaps LB or Irina could add to the blurb above...tell me how they did it too!
You're right AP, women have it in their heads that skinny is sexy. Too bad. There's a nice woman's shape that is neither skinny nor fat that all women can achieve and maintain if they'd be a bit more moderate in what they ate; a bit more active; and a whole lot more realistic about what a woman should look like.
Anorexic, bony bodies are not sexy. Not in men and not in women.
LB - I've had a hard day blogging, it takes numerous tries to get on and post a comment. Is this the Rosie O'Donnell problem again?
I disagree some people are fat and it's not their fault. They need to eat more than they should to get that same full feeling you get when you eat just the normal and right amount of food.
If you begin to eat less, it will be uncomfortable at first, but your body gets used to it before you know it.
I think (because I can relate) that when you make food your "fun", your "comfort" and your best activity, you will think of it often and plan the next meal before you've finished the one you've got.
It's this line of thinking that kept me heavier than I'd like. When I substituted activities (get replacement hobbies) for food thoughts, I lost weight because I wasn't so damn focused on food.
It's part of life: It isn't life itself.
I'm on Weightwatchers right now - since my bad marriage, post-divorce scenario had gotten me into bad eating habits and I knew it. I don't plan on staying on it for more than I paid for, however, it's helped me re-establish the way I USED to eat. I -can- have chocolate cake. I -can- have fast food once in a long while. It's okay to binge a little as long as it's not every day. With that in mind, I've been steadily losing and heading back towards where I had been.
The problem is, when people see me eating less or skipping a meal, they imediately cry anorexia. I don't have a false self-image. I'm not trying to become some heroine chic model, I just want to get down to what my 'norm' always was. I have a big chest. Always have, always will (unless I get cancer, god forbid). As a result, I will always weigh more than the norm, but look healthy at a higher weight. And I resent the accusations of those people who see me succeeding and become determined to twist my overcoming what for me really is a battle into something it isn't. Screw the societal standard. I want to be just right for me.
And I can't believe I typoed heroin to heroine. Man, how's that for braindead? :)Definitely NOT a Freudian slip, there.
echrai said... I just want to get down to what my 'norm' always was. I have a big chest. Always have, always will.
-----
Exactly! echrai's gets it. We are all made differently and have to accept and love our bodies and that doesn't mean getting hugely obese or skinny as a rail.
E says: The problem is, when people see me eating less or skipping a meal, they imediately cry anorexia.
----
Don't you absolutely detest that? You're working on your own issues --and a rotten divorce can wring you dry of hope and sanity. So you start to redo your life and survive the divorce tsunami and someone comes along and tries to sabotage your efforts in healing and growing. Why do people do this?????
My guess is people really don't want you to change. They are afraid that as you change your marital status you might change your relationship with them. Eff them, sorry but if they keep it up they're going to realize their worst fears.
I'm envious of your chest ;-) and I love the fact you understand that your body will never be the heroin waif style and isn't that a wonderful thing, who'd want to look like that?
But you can and do have the body of a heroine! (Let's make good use of that typo!)
We women have to support each other and remind each other that there is no universal standard of beauty. And goddess help us all if we are reduced to body parts and we are not embracing and accepting ourselves as whole women.
The women I've spoken of disappoint me because they're playing games with weight. Playing games with me about their weight. Which also means they're playing games with themselves. That is the stupid part.
PS E-- I've seen your picture and you, my dear, are gorgeous!
Hi - i know women just like the one's you described. They say they never eat anything but they aren't loosing weight either.
lauren, i don't know how to or want to have my own blog but I like to read what other people think. thanks for asking before
lauren i hope I didn't sound rude. I don't want my own blog now for lots of reasons, like 3 kids under 3!
Wecome chrisbilal! -- thanks for stopping by my blog.
I agree, don't think there are too many women making jello molds and fruit cup for dinner anymore. We're all too busy working - or writing on blogs like moi.
Speaking of abs, six packs etc. -that reminds me of beer which of course is the worst drink for a lean body but my favorite... Anyhow, just saw on TV that Becks is coming out with the lowest calorie (I think they said calorie, might be carb but I'm leaning to calorie) beer on the market.
Since I'm a beer drinker I must look into this.
i recently came across your blog and check it regularily. i like what you have to say and can relate to some of your entries, especially this diet one. i by no means need to diet but i know people exactly as you have described and am tired of listening to them wanting to lose weight. know what i did to lose 30 lbs? i started exercising, changed my diet and continue to be active. it did not happen overnight and i will never allow myself to get to 127 again (i'm petite so don't freak about my current weight). however, i remain active so that i can eat just about anything i want. i'm also tired of people wanting instant gratification. the direction our society is headed with "i want and i need it now" attitude is ruining people. ok, enough of that. so please keep blogging!
Welcome kimchee -- thank you for the kind comments. Stop by any time. I agree, the "I want, I need it now" mentality will spawn a generation of people who can't hold a job, who are deeply in debt, who lose all appreciation for anything that takes mare than 2 minutes and will struggle with all addictions because they give into every whim they have instantly and without thought for future consequences.
Post a Comment
<< Home